Skip to main content
In addition to the design and processing requirements for each type of form, other criteria also need to be taken into consideration when choosing a form type. These include printing costs and methods, the number of copies required, the resulting image size, scanning modes, the required degree of recognition accuracy, form processing speed, overall appearance of the forms, how neatly they will be completed, etc. The table below summarizes the advantages and disadvantages of each form type.

Criteria

Dropout Form

Black-and-White Raster Form

Black-and-White Linear Form

Disadvantage

Advantage

Disadvantage

Advantage

Disadvantage

Advantage

Design Complexity

 

Easy to design using any graphics editor.

Text editors offer limited tools for designing this type of form. The size of raster dots is crucial.

  

Easy to design using any graphics editor

Printing

Difficult to print large quantities of good quality forms in-house.

  

Easy to print in-house.

 

Easy to print in-house.

Printing Costs

If professional printing services are used, printing costs are higher compared with black-and- white forms.

  

If professional printing services are used, printing costs are lower compared with dropout forms.

 

If professional printing services are used, printing costs are lower compared with dropout forms

Image Size

 

Image file sizes are smaller.

Image file sizes are larger.

 

Image file sizes are larger.

 

Scanning Mode

Only special scanning modes (color filtering) may be used.

 

Limited range of brightness and contrast settings.

 

Limited range of brightness and contrast settings.

 

Processing Speed

 

Higher average processing speed.

Average processing time is longer, because the images need to be despeckled.

 

Errors are more likely if characters are glued together or overlap field borders.

 

Recognition Quality

 

Very high recognition quality.

 

High recognition quality.

Recognition quality largely depends on how neatly the form has been filled out.

High recognition quality if the form has been filled out correctly.

Location of explanatory text

 

Explanatory text may be placed anywhere, including inside fields (as long it is printed using the same color as the form background).

Explanatory text and other form elements must be carefully arranged on the form.

 

Explanatory text and other form elements must be carefully arranged on the form.

 

Form Appearance and Legibility

Low contrast settings of background and explanatory text may adversely affect form legibility.

Aesthetically pleasing

Less eye-catching design. Lower legibility.

 

Less eye-catching design.

Good legibility.

Neatness of Completion

 

Less sensitive to text overlapping field borders.

Small characters must be written very carefully and be large enough not to be removed as garbage.

Less sensitive to text overlapping field borders.

Very sensitive to text overlapping field borders.